How to Mix Concrete by Hand or in a Drum Mixer
For a few posts, a step or a small pad, mixing concrete by hand in a wheelbarrow or tub is perfectly good. For anything bigger, a rented drum mixer saves your back and gives more consistent batches. Either way, the quality of the concrete depends on the same few habits: measure everything, add water slowly, mix until uniform, and place each batch before it stiffens. This page covers both methods step by step, and the mistakes that cause most problems.
Hand mixing or a mixer?
- Hand mixing suits jobs of up to about 10 to 15 bags of 80 lb premix (roughly 6 to 9 cu ft), or a job you can do in batches over time, such as setting fence posts one at a time.
- A drum mixer suits jobs from there up to a cubic yard or so, especially a slab that must be placed and finished in one session.
- Ready-mix starts to make sense around a cubic yard and above. One cubic yard is 45 bags of 80 lb before waste. See ready-mix truck or bagged concrete.
Work out how many bags you need first with the concrete bag calculator.
Tools and materials
- Wheelbarrow or plastic mixing tub, and a mortar hoe (the kind with holes in the blade) or a square shovel
- A bucket marked with water levels, and a second bucket for measuring dry materials if you are mixing from scratch
- Premixed concrete bags, or Portland cement, clean sand and gravel
- Clean water and a hose, plus a separate bucket of clean water for rinsing skin
- Utility knife for opening bags
- For a drum mixer: a level, firm spot near the pour and a GFCI-protected outlet or a gas model
- Safety gear: alkali-resistant gloves, long sleeves and trousers, waterproof boots, eye protection and a dust mask
Mixing premixed bags by hand
- Measure the water first. Read the bag. A typical 80 lb general-purpose bag starts at about 3 quarts (2.8 L). Have it ready in the marked bucket.
- Open the bag low, slit along the side, and tip it into the tub or barrow while standing upwind with a dust mask on.
- Make a hollow in the middle of the dry mix and pour in about two thirds of the water.
- Pull the dry mix into the water from the edges with the hoe, chopping and turning, until it is all wet.
- Add the remaining water a little at a time, mixing between additions, only until the mix is workable: like thick oatmeal, holding a ridge when sliced with the hoe. Stop before the bag's maximum water.
- Check the corners and bottom for dry powder. Scrape them out and mix again until the color is even.
- Place it promptly. Mix only as much as you can place in the next half hour or so, less in hot weather.
One or two 80 lb bags per batch is plenty for a wheelbarrow; more than that is very hard to turn by hand and heavy to move.
Mixing from cement, sand and gravel by hand
- Measure the materials for your ratio by bucket, not by shovel, for example 1 bucket cement, 2 sand, 3 gravel for a 1:2:3 mix. The mix ratio guide explains the choices.
- Mix the sand and cement dry first until the color is even with no streaks.
- Add the gravel and turn the pile until the stones are evenly spread.
- Make a hollow, add water gradually as above, and mix until uniform. If the sand was damp, you will need noticeably less water.
Using a drum mixer
- Set it up on firm, level ground close to the pour, with a clear barrow route. Plug an electric mixer into a GFCI-protected outlet and keep the cord and motor out of water.
- Check the batch size. A mixer's rated batch capacity is well below the size of the drum. Overfilling spills material and leaves an unmixed core.
- Start the drum turning, then add most of the water first. With premix, add the bags one at a time. Mixing from scratch, a common order is water, then about half the gravel (which scours the drum), then sand and cement, then the rest of the gravel.
- Add the last of the water slowly until the mix tumbles and folds over itself without sticking in a dry ball or slopping.
- Mix for a few minutes after the last material goes in, until the color and consistency are even. Follow the mixer and bag instructions.
- Tip into the barrow with the drum still turning, and keep the next batch going while you place this one.
- Clean as you finish. Run water and a shovelful of gravel in the turning drum to scour it, then rinse. Do not let concrete harden in the drum.
Never reach into a turning drum or put a shovel or hoe inside it while it turns. Switch off and wait for it to stop before scraping.
Common mistakes and how to avoid them
Too much water
The number one cause of weak, dusty, cracked concrete. A soupy mix is easier to place but leaves pores as the extra water leaves. Measure water, add the last of it slowly, and accept a mix that takes some effort to spread. More detail in the water to cement ratio.
Measuring with a shovel
Shovelfuls vary in size by a factor of two. Use buckets or whole bags.
Batches that differ
Different water amounts from batch to batch give patches of different color and strength in a slab. Use the same marked bucket for every batch.
Dry pockets
Unmixed powder in the corners of a barrow or stuck to the back of a drum ends up as weak spots. Scrape and remix.
Re-tempering stiffening concrete
Adding water to a batch that has started to set to loosen it makes it weak. If a batch has stiffened too far to place and compact, discard it.
Old or lumpy cement
Cement that has absorbed moisture has hard lumps that do not crumble between your fingers. It has partly hydrated and will not give full strength.
Dirty materials
Sand with clay or soil, leaves in the gravel, or water with oil or soap in it all weaken the mix. Keep piles on a tarp and covered.
Mixing too far from the pour
Long barrow runs on soft ground shake the stones to the bottom and slow you down. Set up close, and lay planks.
Pouring on frozen or muddy ground, or skipping curing
These are placement problems rather than mixing ones, but they undo good mixing. Never place concrete on frozen ground, and keep new concrete moist and protected; the curing time calculator shows how temperature changes the timeline.
Safety
- Wet concrete burns skin. It is strongly alkaline and the burns may not hurt until hours later. Wear alkali-resistant gloves, long sleeves, long trousers, waterproof boots with trousers over the tops, and eye protection. Wash splashes off promptly with clean water and remove any clothing that wet concrete soaks through. If it gets in your eyes, rinse with clean water for at least 15 minutes and get medical help. Gloves matter even for one bag, because cement can also cause allergic skin reactions.
- Dust. Open and pour bags upwind, wearing a dust mask and eye protection.
- Lifting. 80 lb bags and 94 lb cement bags are heavy. Lift with your legs, keep the load close, get help, and move bags and wet concrete with a barrow filled only partway.
- Mixers. Hands and tools out of a turning drum; electric mixers dry and on a GFCI-protected outlet.