Fly Ash in Concrete: Pros, Cons and Curing Time
Fly ash is the fine powder captured from the exhaust of coal-burning power plants. In concrete it replaces part of the portland cement. Used well, it makes concrete easier to place, less permeable and better at resisting some kinds of chemical attack. Used carelessly, especially in cold weather or with poor curing, it gives slow-setting concrete that is weak at the surface. Here is what it does, the honest pros and cons, and how it changes curing.
What fly ash is
Fly ash is made of tiny glassy spheres, mostly silica, alumina and iron oxide. It is a pozzolan: it does not harden much on its own, but it reacts with the calcium hydroxide that portland cement releases as it hydrates, forming extra strength-giving binder. Because it waits on the cement, its contribution comes later than the cement's.
For concrete it is specified under ASTM C618, in two classes:
- Class F: usually from bituminous or anthracite coal; low in calcium. Purely pozzolanic, slower early strength, and the more effective class against sulfate attack and alkali-silica reaction.
- Class C: usually from lignite or subbituminous coal; higher in calcium, with some cementing ability of its own. Less of a drag on early strength.
It reaches your concrete either as a separate ingredient at the ready-mix plant, or pre-blended in Type IP cement (ASTM C595) or, in India, portland pozzolana cement (PPC, IS 1489), whose fly ash version contains 15% to 35% fly ash.
How much is used
Common replacement levels are roughly 15% to 25% of the total cementitious material by weight, and mixes above about 30% are usually called high-volume fly ash concrete. For concrete exposed to freezing and thawing with deicing salts (ACI 318 exposure class F3, such as driveways and parking slabs in snowy climates), the building code limits fly ash to 25% of the cementitious material, because of the risk of surface scaling. The exact amount belongs to the mix designer and should be proven with trial batches.
Pros
- Workability: the round particles act like ball bearings, so the mix flows, pumps and finishes more easily, often with less water for the same slump. Less water means lower water-cement ratio and less shrinkage.
- Later strength: fly ash concrete keeps gaining strength past 28 days and often ends up stronger than a similar all-portland mix, provided it is cured.
- Lower permeability: the extra binder fills pores, slowing the entry of water and chlorides, which helps protect reinforcing steel.
- Chemical resistance: Class F fly ash in particular improves resistance to sulfate attack and helps control alkali-silica reaction.
- Less heat: lower heat of hydration reduces thermal cracking in thick pours and helps in hot weather.
- Less cement: every pound of cement replaced avoids the CO2 from making it. See lower-carbon concrete.
Cons
- Slower setting: all Class F and most Class C fly ashes lengthen setting time, and the effect is much stronger in cool weather. Finishing crews wait longer.
- Slower early strength: lower strength at 1 to 7 days, particularly with Class F and in the cold. That affects when you can walk on, load or strip forms.
- Curing sensitivity: if the surface dries out early, the pozzolanic reaction stops and the top layer stays weak and porous, which shows up as dusting and scaling.
- Air control: unburned carbon in some fly ashes absorbs air-entraining admixture, making the air content harder to hold steady. Air-entrained mixes need regular testing.
- Variability: fly ash properties depend on the coal and the plant, so color and performance can vary between sources.
Curing time with fly ash
Curing is where fly ash concrete succeeds or fails.
- Keep it moist longer. Plan on at least 7 days of moist curing in mild weather and longer in cool weather, or as the specification requires. Wet burlap, plastic sheeting, ponding or a curing compound all work; see curing concrete.
- Protect from cold. Below about 41 F (5 C), strength gain slows sharply for any concrete and more so with fly ash. Use insulated blankets, and ask the supplier about a lower fly ash share or an accelerator for cold-weather pours.
- Wait for the bleed water. Fly ash mixes may bleed for longer. Do not trowel while water is on the surface.
- Adjust your timetable. The curing time calculator treats blended cements as slower to start and still gaining after 28 days. Foot traffic is reasonable around 30% of design strength; supporting forms wait for about 70% and the engineer's approval. Some specifications measure strength of high-fly-ash concrete at 56 days rather than 28; that is a design decision for the engineer.
Should you use it?
For most ready-mix slabs, paths and foundations, a moderate fly ash share in a mix the supplier has proven locally is normal and works well if you cure it. Tell the supplier what the concrete is for and the expected weather. For a driveway or slab that will see deicing salts, confirm the mix meets the freeze-thaw requirements (air entrainment, water-cement ratio and the 25% fly ash cap). For structural work (footings, foundations, retaining walls, suspended slabs), the mix, strength and SCM limits come from the plans, a structural engineer and the local code.
Safety
- Wet concrete burns skin. It is strongly alkaline; burns may not hurt until hours later. Wear alkali-resistant gloves, long sleeves and trousers, waterproof boots with trousers over or tucked in so concrete cannot get inside, and eye protection. Do not kneel in it without waterproof knee pads. Wash it off promptly with clean water and remove soaked clothing. For eyes, rinse with clean water for at least 15 minutes and get medical help. Cement can cause allergic skin reactions, so wear gloves even for small jobs.
- Dust: open bags of cement or blended cement with a dust mask and eye protection, standing upwind.
- Ready-mix trucks: keep clear of the chute and of the truck's reversing path.