Concrete Testing: Slump, Air, Cylinders and Strength
Testing happens at two levels. Cement is tested at the plant, against the standard printed on the bag. Concrete is tested on site when it arrives (slump, air, temperature) and in a lab weeks later (cylinder strength). Most homeowners pouring a path will never see a test, but anyone ordering ready-mix for a permitted job, or reading a test report, should know what the numbers mean and what they do not.
Tests on cement
Bagged and bulk cement is made to a specification: ASTM C150 (Portland cement Types I to V), ASTM C595 (blended cements such as Type IL) or ASTM C1157 (performance cements) in the US, and the relevant Indian Standards for OPC 43, OPC 53 and PPC, with test methods in the IS 4031 series. The plant runs the tests and issues a mill test report. The main ones:
| Test | US method | What it checks |
|---|---|---|
| Fineness (Blaine air permeability) | ASTM C204 | Particle surface area; finer cement reacts faster |
| Normal consistency | ASTM C187 | Water needed for a standard paste, used to run the setting test |
| Setting time (Vicat needle) | ASTM C191 | That the paste does not set too fast to place or too slowly |
| Soundness (autoclave expansion) | ASTM C151 | That hardened paste will not expand and crack later |
| Compressive strength of mortar cubes | ASTM C109 | Strength of 2 in (50 mm) cubes of a standard mortar at set ages |
| Chemical analysis | ASTM C114 | Composition limits in the specification |
None of these is a DIY test. What you can check yourself is whether a bag has been stored badly and taken on moisture; see how to tell if cement has gone off.
Tests on fresh concrete
Sampling (ASTM C172)
Every test is only as good as the sample. For a truck, the sample is taken from the middle of the load, not the first or last of it, and combined into one composite sample. Slump, air and temperature tests start within 5 minutes of getting the sample, and cylinders are molded within 15 minutes.
Slump (ASTM C143)
The slump test measures consistency: how stiff or fluid the concrete is. It is a quick check that a load matches the mix that was ordered, and the clearest way to catch water added on site.
- Dampen the slump cone (12 in (300 mm) tall, 8 in (200 mm) across the bottom, 4 in (100 mm) across the top) and stand it on a flat, damp, non-absorbent base, holding it down by the foot pieces.
- Fill it in three layers of equal volume, rodding each layer 25 times with a 5/8 in (16 mm) bullet-nosed rod.
- Strike off the top level, clear spilled concrete from around the base.
- Lift the cone straight up in about 5 seconds (5 plus or minus 2), with no twisting or sideways movement.
- Measure the drop from the top of the cone to the displaced center of the concrete. That is the slump.
From the start of filling to lifting the cone should take no more than about 2-1/2 minutes, without stopping. If the concrete shears off to one side, repeat it. The specification sets the target slump; a load well over it usually means extra water and lower strength. Water-reducing admixtures can raise slump without adding water, so a high slump is not automatically a problem when the mix was designed that way. See concrete admixtures.
Air content, density and temperature
- Air content of air-entrained concrete is measured with a pressure meter (ASTM C231) for normal aggregates, or a volumetric (roll-a-meter) method (ASTM C173) for lightweight aggregates. Too little air and the concrete will not resist freezing; too much and strength drops.
- Density (unit weight) (ASTM C138) is the weight of a known volume, and from it the yield, which shows whether you received the volume you paid for.
- Temperature (ASTM C1064) matters in hot and cold weather, and many specifications set limits.
Strength cylinders
Making them (ASTM C31)
Cylinders are cast on site in plastic molds, 6 x 12 in (150 x 300 mm) or the smaller 4 x 8 in (100 x 200 mm), filled in layers and rodded as the standard sets out. For the first day or two they stay on site, protected from moisture loss and kept in the standard temperature range of 60 to 80 F (16 to 27 C). Then they go to the lab for moist curing until they are tested. A cylinder left in the sun on a truck bed, or frozen overnight, will test low for reasons that have nothing to do with the concrete in the slab.
Standard-cured cylinders show whether the concrete as delivered met its specified strength. Field-cured cylinders, kept beside the structure, show the strength of the concrete in place, and are what an engineer uses to decide when to strip forms or load a member.
Breaking them (ASTM C39)
The lab crushes each cylinder in a compression machine and divides the failure load by the cross-section area to give psi or MPa. Breaks are usually scheduled at 7 and 28 days, sometimes with spares held for 56 days on blended-cement mixes that keep gaining strength.
Reading a strength report
Under ACI 318, a strength test is the average of at least two 6 x 12 in cylinders, or at least three 4 x 8 in cylinders, from the same sample, broken at 28 days (or the age the designer specified). The concrete is accepted when both of these hold:
- Every average of three consecutive strength tests equals or exceeds the specified strength (f'c).
- No single strength test falls below f'c by more than 500 psi (3.5 MPa) when f'c is 5,000 psi or less, or by more than 10 percent of f'c when f'c is higher.
So for a 4,000 psi mix, a single result of 3,600 psi is not a failure on its own, but 3,400 psi needs investigation.
What the 7-day result means
The 7-day break is an early warning, not a pass or fail. As a rough guide, and matching our curing time calculator at about 68 F (20 C), concrete reaches about 70 percent of its 28-day strength at 7 days with ordinary Portland cement, about 80 percent with Type III, and about 60 percent with blended cements (fly ash, slag, PPC). Cold weather lowers all of these. A low 7-day result on a blended mix in winter is often normal.
When results come back low
- Check the testing first. How were the cylinders handled, cured and transported? Were they molded within the time limit? Low results from one set while others are fine often point to the cylinders.
- Review the delivery tickets. Water added on site, a long wait in the truck, or a wrong mix code all show up here.
- Test the concrete in place. The engineer may order cores drilled from the structure (ASTM C42). Under ACI 318, the concrete in that area is considered adequate when the average of three cores is at least 85 percent of f'c and no single core is below 75 percent. Rebound hammers (ASTM C805) give a quick comparison between areas but are not a substitute for cores.
- Let the engineer decide. Low strength in a structural element is a design question: whether it can carry its loads, needs strengthening, or must come out.
Testing on a small or DIY job
For a path, patio or shed base, the practical quality controls are simple: order the mix you need, check the delivery ticket matches it, refuse water added beyond what the supplier allows, measure ingredients the same way for every batch if you mix your own, and cure properly. Use the mix ratio calculator to keep batches consistent. Footings, foundations, suspended slabs and anything carrying a building usually need a permit, and the inspector or engineer will say what testing is required.
Safety
- Fresh concrete is strongly alkaline and can burn skin, with no pain until hours later. Wear alkali-resistant gloves, long sleeves, waterproof boots and eye protection while sampling and rodding. Wash splashes off with clean water; rinse eyes with clean water for at least 15 minutes and get medical help.
- Stay clear of a ready-mix truck's chute while it swings and out of its reversing path. Take samples only when the driver knows you are there.
- A filled 6 x 12 in cylinder weighs around 30 lb (14 kg). Lift with your legs.